Top Real Estate Agents in Carmel, CA
Last updated November 2026
These are the 16 individual agents ranked in Carmel, California for 2026, ordered by 2025 closed sales volume. Together they closed $457.79M across 183 transaction sides. The list covers agents whose office is in Carmel, a market that takes in the village of Carmel-by-the-Sea, Carmel Point and the Carmel Highlands. As of November 16, 2026, the median list price in Carmel was $3,299,000, according to RealTrends.
| Rank | Name & company | Volume | Sides | City |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Shelly LynchCarmel Realty Company | $188.36M | 34 | Carmel, CA |
| 2 | Ryan MelcherSotheby's International Realty | $97.66M | 35 | Carmel, CA |
| 3 | Vilia Kakis GillesSotheby's International Realty | $20.08M | 13 | Carmel, CA |
| 4 | Melissa ChernetskyThe Real Brokerage | $18.58M | 14 | Carmel, CA |
| 5 | Susan CardinaleSotheby's International Realty | $16.63M | 13 | Carmel, CA |
| 6 | Nick GlaserSotheby's International Realty | $15.70M | 7 | Carmel, CA |
| 7 | Renee CataniaSotheby's International Realty | $13.14M | 9 | Carmel, CA |
| 8 | Patricia RossSotheby's International Realty | $12.33M | 7 | Carmel, CA |
| 9 | Mike MezaSotheby's International Realty | $11.34M | 8 | Carmel, CA |
| 10 | Sara PhelpsSotheby's International Realty | $10.05M | 12 | Carmel, CA |
| 11 | Young Seon MyongSotheby's International Realty | $9.65M | 6 | Carmel, CA |
| 12 | Ryan WillisSotheby's International Realty | $9.62M | 4 | Carmel, CA |
| 13 | Michele AltmanSotheby's International Realty | $9.49M | 7 | Carmel, CA |
| 14 | Tammy LaSalaSotheby's International Realty | $9.44M | 8 | Carmel, CA |
| 15 | Ryan KeenanSotheby's International Realty | $8.12M | 1 | Carmel, CA |
| 16 | Natalie PolingSotheby's International Realty | $7.60M | 5 | Carmel, CA |
Where Carmel's sales volume sits
Sotheby's International Realty accounts for 14 of the 16 ranked agents and $250.85M of the combined volume, or 55% of the total. Carmel Realty Company is represented by one agent, the #1 agent by volume, and The Real Brokerage by one.
Volume by brokerage
Most transactions closed
How to read this ranking
- Volume is the total dollar value of closed sales an agent was credited with in 2025. Volume rises fast in a market where single homes sell for several million dollars.
- Sides count transactions. Representing the seller is one side and representing the buyer is one side, so an agent who represents both in one sale earns two.
- City is the office city published with the ranking. An agent ranked in Carmel can also sell in Pebble Beach, Carmel Valley or Monterey.
- The ranking is based on verified sales data. The source is named once, in the table footer.
Questions about the Carmel ranking
Who is the top real estate agent in Carmel, CA?
Based on 2025 closed sales volume, Shelly Lynch of Carmel Realty Company is the top-ranked agent in Carmel, with $188.36M across 34 sides. Ryan Melcher closed the most transactions on the list, with 35 sides.
Which agents on this list work in Carmel-by-the-Sea village?
All 16 agents are ranked to Carmel offices. Susan Cardinale is often associated with Carmel-by-the-Sea village homes, where her sold history includes five village sales from about $1.96M to $3.4M.
What does sales volume mean?
Sales volume is the combined dollar value of the closed sales an agent was credited with in 2025. It favors agents who handle higher-priced homes.
What is a transaction side?
Each sale has two sides, the seller side and the buyer side. An agent who represents both parties in one sale is credited with two sides.
How are agents assigned to Carmel?
Agents are placed by the office city published with the ranking. That is where their office is, not the only place they sell.
What period does this ranking cover?
The figures are 2025 closed sales, published in the 2026 rankings. The page is reviewed when new figures are released.
Should I look at volume or sides?
Volume shows the price range an agent works in, while sides show how many deals they close. Looking at both gives a fuller picture.
What is the difference between a buyer's agent and a listing agent?
A listing agent represents the seller and markets the home. A buyer's agent represents the buyer, finds homes and negotiates the purchase.
Brokerages represented
About this list
Data source: RealTrends Verified 2026 rankings for Carmel, CA, individual agents by volume, based on 2025 closed sales. Not affiliated with RealTrends or any brokerage. Last updated November 2026.